{ "@context": { "owl": "http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#", "rdf": "http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#", "rdfs": "http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#", "xsd": "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#", "trig": "http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/rdfg-1/", "foaf": "http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/", "dcterms": "http://purl.org/dc/terms/", "sioc": "http://rdfs.org/sioc/ns#", "oa": "http://www.openannotation.org/ns/", "idea": "http://purl.org/catalyst/idea#", "ibis": "http://purl.org/catalyst/ibis#", "situation": "http://purl.org/conversence/situation#", "assembl": "http://purl.org/assembl/core#", "catalyst": "http://purl.org/catalyst/core#", "version": "http://purl.org/catalyst/version#", "vote": "http://purl.org/catalyst/vote#", "eg_site": "http://www.assembl.net/", "eg_d1": "http://www.assembl.net/discussion/1/", "aif": "http://www.arg.dundee.ac.uk/aif", "Graph": "trig:Graph", "title": "dcterms:title", "alternative": "dcterms:alternative", "dclanguage": "dcterms:language", "format": "dcterms:format", "conformsTo": {"@id":"dcterms:conformsTo", "@type": "@id"}, "created": {"@id": "dcterms:created", "@type": "xsd:dateTime"}, "date": {"@id": "dcterms:date", "@type": "xsd:date"}, "description": "dcterms:description", "modified": {"@id": "dcterms:modified", "@type": "xsd:dateTime"}, "hasPart": {"@id": "dcterms:hasPart", "@type": "@id"}, "isPartOf": {"@id": "dcterms:isPartOf", "@type": "@id"}, "AbstractionStatement": "idea:AbstractionStatement", "CausalInference": "idea:CausalInference", "CausalStatement": "idea:CausalStatement", "ComparisonStatement": "idea:ComparisonStatement", "ContextOfExpression": "idea:ContextOfExpression", "DirectedIdeaRelation": "idea:DirectedIdeaRelation", "DistinctionStatement": "idea:DistinctionStatement", "EquivalenceStatement": "idea:EquivalenceStatement", "GenericIdea": "idea:GenericIdea", "GenericIdeaNode": "idea:GenericIdeaNode", "IdeaRelation": "idea:IdeaRelation", "InclusionRelation": "idea:InclusionRelation", "MutualRelevanceStatement": "idea:MutualRelevanceStatement", "Question": "idea:Question", "WholePartRelation": "idea:WholePartRelation", "abstracts": {"@id": "idea:abstracts", "@type": "@id"}, "compares": {"@id": "idea:compares", "@type": "@id"}, "ideaHasPart": {"@id": "idea:hasPart", "@type": "@id"}, "ideaIsPartOf": {"@id": "idea:isPartOf", "@type": "@id"}, "includes": {"@id": "idea:includes", "@type": "@id"}, "includedIn": {"@id": "idea:includedIn", "@type": "@id"}, "is_abstracted": {"@id": "idea:is_abstracted", "@type": "@id"}, "is_abstraction_of": {"@id": "idea:is_abstraction_of", "@type": "@id"}, "is_compared": {"@id": "idea:is_compared", "@type": "@id"}, "is_compared_to": {"@id": "idea:is_compared_to", "@type": "@id"}, "is_specialized": {"@id": "idea:is_specialized", "@type": "@id"}, "relates_idea": {"@id": "idea:relates_idea", "@type": "@id"}, "source_idea": {"@id": "idea:source_idea", "@type": "@id"}, "target_idea": {"@id": "idea:target_idea", "@type": "@id"}, "specializes": {"@id": "idea:specializes", "@type": "@id"}, "Argument": "ibis:Argument", "ArgumentApplication": "ibis:ArgumentApplication", "ArgumentOpposesIdea": "ibis:ArgumentOpposesIdea", "ArgumentSupportsIdea": "ibis:ArgumentSupportsIdea", "Criterion": "ibis:Criterion", "CriterionApplication": "ibis:CriterionApplication", "Decision": "ibis:Decision", "Issue": "ibis:Issue", "IssueQuestions": "ibis:IssueQuestions", "IdeaMap": "idea:Map", "Position": "ibis:Position", "PositionRespondsToIssue": "ibis:PositionRespondsToIssue", "Reference": "ibis:Reference", "IssueAppliesTo": "ibis:IssueAppliesTo", "argumentAdressesCriterion": {"@id": "ibis:argumentAdressesCriterion", "@type": "@id"}, "argument_arguing": {"@id": "ibis:argument_arguing", "@type": "@id"}, "criterionOpposes": {"@id": "ibis:criterionOpposes", "@type": "@id"}, "criterionSupports": {"@id": "ibis:criterionSupports", "@type": "@id"}, "ideaInMap": {"@id": "idea:inMap", "@type": "@id"}, "response_issue": {"@id": "ibis:response_issue", "@type": "@id"}, "response_position": {"@id": "ibis:response_position", "@type": "@id"}, "applicable_issue": {"@id": "ibis:applicable_issue", "@type": "@id"}, "Situation": "situation:Situation", "Initiative": "situation:Initiative", "Evaluation": "situation:Evaluation", "ExpectedOutcome": "situation:ExpectedOutcome", "KnownExampleSituation": "situation:KnownExampleSituation", "EvaluateRegardingIssue": "situation:EvaluateRegardingIssue", "ConcreteSituation": "situation:ConcreteSituation", "initial_situation": {"@id": "situation:initial_situation", "@type": "@id"}, "expected_outcome": {"@id": "situation:expected_outcome", "@type": "@id"}, "abstract_situation": {"@id": "situation:abstract_situation", "@type": "@id"}, "concrete_example": {"@id": "situation:concrete_example", "@type": "@id"}, "evaluates_situation": {"@id": "situation:evaluates_situation", "@type": "@id"}, "regarding_issue": {"@id": "situation:regarding_issue", "@type": "@id"}, "Person": "foaf:Person", "Agent": "foaf:Agent", "Organization": "foaf:Organization", "familyName": "foaf:familyName", "firstName": "foaf:firstName", "fname": "foaf:name", "homepage": {"@id": "foaf:homepage", "@type": "@id"}, "img": {"@id": "foaf:img", "@type": "@id"}, "depiction": {"@id": "foaf:depiction", "@type": "@id"}, "mbox": {"@id": "foaf:mbox", "@type": "@id"}, "account": {"@id": "foaf:account", "@type": "@id"}, "Community": "sioc:Community", "Container": "sioc:Container", "Forum": "sioc:Forum", "SItem": "sioc:Item", "SPost": "sioc:Post", "Role": "sioc:Role", "SSite": "sioc:Site", "Space": "sioc:Space", "Thread": "sioc:Thread", "UserAccount": "sioc:UserAccount", "Usergroup": "sioc:Usergroup", "about": "sioc:about", "addressed_to": "sioc:addressed_to", "content": "sioc:content", "email": "sioc:email", "email_sha1": "sioc:email_sha1", "hasFunction": "sioc:hasFunction", "id": "sioc:id", "ip_address": "sioc:ip_address", "last_activity_date": "sioc:last_activity_date", "last_item_date": "sioc:last_item_date", "last_reply_date": "sioc:last_reply_date", "name": "sioc:name", "note": "sioc:note", "topic": "sioc:topic", "num_authors": {"@id": "sioc:num_authors", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "num_items": {"@id": "sioc:num_items", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "num_replies": {"@id": "sioc:num_replies", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "num_threads": {"@id": "sioc:num_threads", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "num_views": {"@id": "sioc:num_views", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "account_of": {"@id": "sioc:account_of", "@type": "@id"}, "administrator_of": {"@id": "sioc:administrator_of", "@type": "@id"}, "attachment": {"@id": "sioc:attachment", "@type": "@id"}, "avatar": {"@id": "sioc:avatar", "@type": "@id"}, "container_of": {"@id": "sioc:container_of", "@type": "@id"}, "creator_of": {"@id": "sioc:creator_of", "@type": "@id"}, "earlier_version": {"@id": "sioc:earlier_version", "@type": "@id"}, "embeds_knowledge": {"@id": "sioc:embeds_knowledge", "@type": "@id"}, "feed": {"@id": "sioc:feed", "@type": "@id"}, "follows": {"@id": "sioc:follows", "@type": "@id"}, "function_of": {"@id": "sioc:function_of", "@type": "@id"}, "has_administrator": {"@id": "sioc:has_administrator", "@type": "@id"}, "has_container": {"@id": "sioc:has_container", "@type": "@id"}, "has_creator": {"@id": "sioc:has_creator", "@type": "@id"}, "has_discussion": {"@id": "sioc:has_discussion", "@type": "@id"}, "has_function": {"@id": "sioc:has_function", "@type": "@id"}, "has_host": {"@id": "sioc:has_host", "@type": "@id"}, "has_member": {"@id": "sioc:has_member", "@type": "@id"}, "has_moderator": {"@id": "sioc:has_moderator", "@type": "@id"}, "has_modifier": {"@id": "sioc:has_modifier", "@type": "@id"}, "has_owner": {"@id": "sioc:has_owner", "@type": "@id"}, "has_parent": {"@id": "sioc:has_parent", "@type": "@id"}, "has_reply": {"@id": "sioc:has_reply", "@type": "@id"}, "has_scope": {"@id": "sioc:has_scope", "@type": "@id"}, "has_space": {"@id": "sioc:has_space", "@type": "@id"}, "has_subscriber": {"@id": "sioc:has_subscriber", "@type": "@id"}, "has_usergroup": {"@id": "sioc:has_usergroup", "@type": "@id"}, "host_of": {"@id": "sioc:host_of", "@type": "@id"}, "later_version": {"@id": "sioc:later_version", "@type": "@id"}, "latest_version": {"@id": "sioc:latest_version", "@type": "@id"}, "link": {"@id": "sioc:link", "@type": "@id"}, "links_to": {"@id": "sioc:links_to", "@type": "@id"}, "member_of": {"@id": "sioc:member_of", "@type": "@id"}, "moderator_of": {"@id": "sioc:moderator_of", "@type": "@id"}, "modifier_of": {"@id": "sioc:modifier_of", "@type": "@id"}, "next_by_date": {"@id": "sioc:next_by_date", "@type": "@id"}, "next_version": {"@id": "sioc:next_version", "@type": "@id"}, "owner_of": {"@id": "sioc:owner_of", "@type": "@id"}, "parent_of": {"@id": "sioc:parent_of", "@type": "@id"}, "previous_by_date": {"@id": "sioc:previous_by_date", "@type": "@id"}, "previous_version": {"@id": "sioc:previous_version", "@type": "@id"}, "related_to": {"@id": "sioc:related_to", "@type": "@id"}, "reply_of": {"@id": "sioc:reply_of", "@type": "@id"}, "scope_of": {"@id": "sioc:scope_of", "@type": "@id"}, "sibling": {"@id": "sioc:sibling", "@type": "@id"}, "space_of": {"@id": "sioc:space_of", "@type": "@id"}, "subscriber_of": {"@id": "sioc:subscriber_of", "@type": "@id"}, "usergroup_of": {"@id": "sioc:usergroup_of", "@type": "@id"}, "CIdea": "catalyst:Idea", "Post": "catalyst:Post", "Site": "catalyst:Site", "Item": "catalyst:Item", "Map": "catalyst:Map", "inMap": {"@id": "catalyst:inMap", "@type": "@id"}, "primaryMap": {"@id": "catalyst:primaryMap", "@type": "@id"}, "Conversation": "catalyst:Conversation", "ParticipantGroup": "catalyst:ParticipantGroup", "Participants": "catalyst:Participants", "Excerpt": "catalyst:Excerpt", "ExcerptTarget": "catalyst:ExcerptTarget", "extractRelevantToIdea": {"@id": "catalyst:extractRelevantToIdea", "@type": "@id"}, "expressesIdea": {"@id": "catalyst:expressesIdea", "@type": "@id"}, "Ideas": "catalyst:Ideas", "relevantToConversation": {"@id": "catalyst:relevantToConversation", "@type": "@id"}, "participants": {"@id": "catalyst:participants", "@type": "@id"}, "uses_source": {"@id": "catalyst:uses_source", "@type": "@id"}, "data_graph": {"@id": "catalyst:data_graph", "@type": "@id"}, "user_graph": {"@id": "catalyst:user_graph", "@type": "@id"}, "pseudonym_scope": {"@id": "catalyst:pseudonym_scope", "@type": "@id"}, "history_graph": {"@id": "catalyst:history_graph", "@type": "@id"}, "full_dataService": {"@id": "catalyst:full_dataService", "@type": "@id"}, "data_selectionService": {"@id": "catalyst:data_selectionService", "@type": "@id"}, "sparqlService": {"@id": "catalyst:sparqlService", "@type": "@id"}, "ideasService": {"@id": "catalyst:ideasService", "@type": "@id"}, "usersService": {"@id": "catalyst:usersService", "@type": "@id"}, "messagesService": {"@id": "catalyst:messagesService", "@type": "@id"}, "pseudonymsService": {"@id": "catalyst:pseudonymsService", "@type": "@id"}, "message_sourcesService": {"@id": "catalyst:message_sourcesService", "@type": "@id"}, "votesService": {"@id": "catalyst:votesService", "@type": "@id"}, "historyService": {"@id": "catalyst:historyService", "@type": "@id"}, "MailingList": "assembl:MailingList", "link_order": {"@id": "assembl:link_order", "@type": "xsd:float"}, "db_id": {"@id": "assembl:db_id", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "in_conversation": {"@id": "assembl:in_conversation", "@type": "@id"}, "has_origin": {"@id": "assembl:has_origin", "@type": "@id"}, "postExtractRelatedToIdea": {"@id": "assembl:postExtractRelatedToIdea", "@type": "@id"}, "resourceExpressesIdea": {"@id": "assembl:resourceExpressesIdea", "@type": "@id"}, "postLinkedToIdea": {"@id": "assembl:postLinkedToIdea", "@type": "@id"}, "postRelatedToIdea": {"@id": "assembl:postRelatedToIdea", "@type": "@id"}, "RootIdea": "assembl:RootIdea", "PostSource": "assembl:PostSource", "Annotation": "oa:Annotation", "SpecificResource": "oa:SpecificResource", "TextPositionSelector": "oa:TextPositionSelector", "FragmentSelector": "oa:FragmentSelector", "TextQuoteSelector": "oa:TextQuoteSelector", "exact": "oa:exact", "prefix": "oa:prefix", "suffix": "oa:suffix", "start": {"@id": "oa:start", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "end": {"@id": "oa:end", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "hasBody": {"@id": "oa:hasBody", "@type": "@id"}, "hasSelector": {"@id": "oa:hasSelector", "@type": "@id"}, "hasSource": {"@id": "oa:hasSource", "@type": "@id"}, "hasTarget": {"@id": "oa:hasTarget", "@type": "@id"}, "annotatedAt": {"@id": "oa:annotatedAt", "@type":"xsd:dateTime"}, "serializedBy": {"@id": "oa:serializedBy", "@type":"@id"}, "BinaryVote": "vote:BinaryVote", "LickertRange": "vote:LickertRange", "LickertVote": "vote:LickertVote", "OrderingVote": "vote:OrderingVote", "Vote": "vote:Vote", "lickert_in_range": {"@id": "vote:lickert_in_range", "@type": "@id"}, "lickert_value": {"@id": "vote:lickert_value", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "max": {"@id": "vote:max", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "min": {"@id": "vote:min", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "ordered_ideas": {"@id": "vote:ordered_ideas", "@type": "@id"}, "positive": {"@id": "vote:positive", "@type": "xsd:boolean"}, "vote_subject": {"@id": "vote:subject", "@type": "@id"}, "vote_subject_node": {"@id": "vote:subject_node", "@type": "@id"}, "vote_subject_link": {"@id": "vote:subject_link", "@type": "@id"}, "voter": {"@id": "vote:voter", "@type": "@id"}, "Annotate": "version:Annotate", "ApprovalChange": "version:ApprovalChange", "Create": "version:Create", "Delete": "version:Delete", "Move": "version:Move", "ObjectSnapshot": "version:ObjectSnapshot", "PerUserStateChange": "version:PerUserStateChange", "PerUserUpdate": "version:PerUserUpdate", "ReadStatusChange": "version:ReadStatusChange", "StateChange": "version:StateChange", "Tombstone": "version:Tombstone", "Update": "version:Update", "affected_object": {"@id": "version:affected_object", "@type": "@id"}, "affected_state": {"@id": "version:affected_state", "@type": "@id"}, "annotation_target": {"@id": "version:annotation_target", "@type": "@id"}, "create_from": {"@id": "version:create_from", "@type": "@id"}, "has_snapshot": {"@id": "version:has_snapshot", "@type": "@id"}, "new_links": {"@id": "version:new_links", "@type": "@id"}, "old_links": {"@id": "version:old_links", "@type": "@id"}, "previous_snapshot": {"@id": "version:previous_snapshot", "@type": "@id"}, "revision": {"@id": "version:revision", "@type": "xsd:integer"}, "snapshot": {"@id": "version:snapshot", "@type": "@id"}, "snapshot_of": {"@id": "version:snapshot_of", "@type": "@id"}, "state_transition": {"@id": "version:state_transition", "@type": "@id"}, "target_snapshot": {"@id": "version:target_snapshot", "@type": "@id"}, "tombstone": {"@id": "version:tombstone", "@type": "@id"}, "updated_value": {"@id": "version:updated_value", "@type": "@id"}, "values_added": {"@id": "version:updated_value", "@type": "@id"}, "values_removed": {"@id": "version:updated_value", "@type": "@id"}, "what": {"@id": "version:what", "@type": "@id"}, "when": {"@id": "version:when", "@type": "xsd:dateTime"}, "who": {"@id": "version:who", "@type": "@id"}, "sameAs": {"@id": "owl:sameAs", "@type": "@id"}, "Statement": "rdf:Statement", "Class": {"@id": "owl:Class", "@type": "@id"}, "Property": "rdf:Property", "inverseOf": {"@id": "owl:inverseOf", "@type": "@id"}, "subClassOf": {"@id": "rfds:subClassOf", "@type": "@id"}, "subPropertyOf": {"@id": "rdfs:subPropertyOf", "@type": "@id"}, "domain": {"@id": "rdfs:domain", "@type": "@id"}, "range": {"@id": "rdfs:range", "@type": "@id"}, "isDefinedBy": {"@id": "rdfs:isDefinedBy", "@type": "@id"}, "label": {"@id": "rdfs:label"}, "rdfcomment": {"@id": "rdfs:comment"}, "subject": {"@id": "rdf:subject", "@type": "@id"}, "predicate": {"@id": "rdf:predicate", "@type": "@id"}, "object": {"@id": "rdf:object", "@type": "@id"} } }